AG2-329 Phase II System Impact Study Report
v1.00 released 2026-06-03 18:45
S Berwick - Galion 345 kV
156.0 MW Capacity / 200.0 MW Energy
Introduction
This Phase II System Impact Study (SIS) Report has been prepared in accordance with the PJM Open Access Transmission Tariff, Part VII, Subpart D, section 310 for New Service Requests (projects) in Transition Cycle 2 (TC2). The Project Developer/Eligible Customer (developer) is Wombat Solar LLC, and the Transmission Provider (TP) is PJM Interconnection, LLC (PJM). The interconnected Transmission Owner (TO) is AEP Indiana Michigan Transmission Company, Inc..
Preface
The Phase II System Impact Study is conducted on an aggregate basis within a New Services Request’s Cycle, and results are provided in both (i) a single Cycle summary format and (ii) an individual project-level basis. The Phase II System Impact Study Results (for both the summary and individual reports) will be publicly available on PJM’s website. Project Developers must obtain the results from the website.
In accordance with PJM Manual 14H, section 4.5, PJM takes the following actions during the Phase II System Impact Study:
- PJM will retool load flow results from the Phase I System Impact Study (summer peak, winter peak and light load) based on decisions made by Project Developers or Eligible Customers during Decision Point I.
- PJM will conduct any required voltage analyses.
- PJM will perform short circuit and stability analyses as required.
- PJM will coordinate with the Affected System to confirm which projects in the PJM Cycle will require Affected System studies. If the Affected System Operator indicates that an Affected System study is required, PJM will:
- Notify the Project Developer or Eligible Customer of the need for an Affected System study and the requirement to execute an Affected System study agreement with the impacted Affected System Operator, and;
- Include the results of the Affected System Operator’s Affected System Study in the Phase II System Impact Study results, if applicable and available.
- The Phase II System Impact Study Results will be publicly available on PJM’s website. Project Developers and Eligible Customers must obtain the results from the website.
The Transmission Owner takes the following actions during the Phase II System Impact Study:
- Verify Interconnection Facilities and Network Upgrades required to accommodate the New Service Request.
- Perform a Facilities Study. The Facilities Study in Phase II System Impact Study phase will be for the physical Interconnection Facilities. The Facilities Study requirements are outlined in Attachment C of this manual. The study will be conducted pursuant to Tariff, Part VII, Subpart D, section 307(A)(7) and Tariff, Part VIII, Subpart C, section 404(A)(7).
Decision Point II Requirements
At the close of Phase II System Impact Study, PJM will initiate Decision Point II (DP2). During DP2, the Project Developer will have 30 days to decide whether to proceed with their project. If the Project Developer elects to proceed, they should provide the elements defined in the PJM Open Access Transmission Tariff, Part VII, Subpart D, section 311.A. Additional information on these elements is available in PJM Manual 14H sections 4.6, 6, and 7.
Allowable project modifications at Decision Point II are defined in PJM Open Access Transmission Tariff, Part VII, Subpart D, section 311.B. Additional information regarding allowable project modifications can be found in PJM Manual 14H, section 9.8.
Adverse Test Eligibility
This New Service Request meets the Adverse Study Impact Criteria and has the option to either move forward in the Cycle process or withdraw at DP2 with Readiness Deposits refunded. See Readiness Deposit calculation below.
This section details whether a Project Developer or Eligible Customer qualifies for the Adverse Study Impact clause outlined in the PJM OATT, Part VII, Subpart D, section 311.B and Manual 14H, section 6.2.2. In order to qualify for an Adverse Study Impact at Decision Point II, the Network Upgrade cost from Phase I to Phase II must:
- Increase overall by 25% or more
- Increases by more than $10,000 per MW (Includes Costs identified in Affected System studies)
If a New Service Request meets the criteria above and chooses to withdraw the request, PJM will refund the cumulative Readiness Deposit amounts paid at the Application Phase and at Decision Point I (RD1 and RD2, respectively).
The below calculations show the computation of this New Service Request's Adverse Study Impact
General
The Project Developer has proposed a Storage facility located in the AEP Indiana Michigan Transmission Company, Inc. zone — Wyandot County, Ohio. The installed facilities will have a total capability of 200.0 MW with 156.0 MW of this output being recognized by PJM as Capacity.Project Information
Physical Interconnection Facility Study
The transmission owner has completed the Physical Interconnection Facilities Study. This report is available for download.
Point of Interconnection
AG2-329 will interconnect on the American Electric Power transmission system by tapping the South Berwick - Galion 345 kV Line.
Cost Summary
The table below shows a summary of the total cost estimates for this New Service Request project. In Phase II SIS, the interconnected Transmission Owner has performed a facilities study for both the Transmission Owner Interconnection Facilities (TOIF) and Physical Interconnection Network Upgrades. The System Reliability Network Upgrade shown in the table are planning level cost estimates which are subject to change as a result of a facility study performed by the TO during Phase III System Impact Study.
Based on the Phase II SIS results, the AG2-329 project has the following allocation of costs for interconnection. The cost contribution towards Readiness Deposit #3 are also shown below.
| Cost Summary | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Description | Cost Allocated to AG2-329 | Cost Subject to Readiness* | Cost Subject to Adverse |
| Transmission Owner Interconnection Facilities (TOIF) | $1,659,783 | $0 | $0 |
| Other Scope | $1,117,553 | $0 | $0 |
| Option To Build Oversight | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Physical Interconnection Network Upgrades | |||
| Stand Alone Network Upgrades | $27,023,419 | $27,023,419 | $27,023,419 |
| Network Upgrades | $1,108,441 | $1,108,441 | $1,108,441 |
| System Reliability Network Upgrades | |||
| Steady State Thermal & Voltage | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Transient Stability | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Short Circuit | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Transmission Owner Analysis | |||
| SubRegional | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Distribution | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Affected System Reinforcements | |||
| AFS - PJM Violations | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| AFS - Non-PJM Violations | $0 | $0 | $0 |
| Total | $30,909,196 | $28,131,860 | $28,131,860 |
* Contributes to calculation for Readiness Deposit #3 (RD3). See Readiness Deposit section of report for additional detail.
Definitions
Transmission Owner Interconnection Facilities: Facilities that are owned, controlled, operated and maintained by the Transmission Owner on the Transmission Owner’s side of the Point of Change of Ownership to the Point of Interconnection, including any modifications, additions or upgrades made to such facilities and equipment, that are necessary to physically and electrically interconnect the Generating Facility with the Transmission System or interconnected distribution facilities.
Stand Alone Network Upgrades: Network Upgrades, which are not part of an Affected System, which a Project Developer may construct without affecting day-to-day operations (e.g. taking a transmission outage) of the Transmission System during their construction.
Network Upgrades: Modifications or additions to transmission-related facilities that are integrated with and support the Transmission Provider’s overall Transmission System for the general benefit of all users of such Transmission System. Network Upgrades have no impact or potential impact on the Transmission System until the final tie-in is complete.
Notes
Note 1: PJM Open Access Transmission Tariff (OATT), Part VII, Subpart D, section 307.5 outlines cost allocation rules. The rules are further clarified in PJM Manual 14H, section 4.2.6. PJM shall identify the New Service Requests in the Cycle contributing to the need for the required Network Upgrades within the Cycle. All New Service Requests that contribute to the need for a Network Upgrade will receive cost allocation for that upgrade pursuant to each New Service Request’s contribution to the reliability violation identified on the transmission system in accordance with PJM Manuals.
Note 2: There will be no inter-Cycle cost allocation for Interconnection Facilities or Network Upgrades identified in the System Impact Study costs identified in a Cycle; all such costs shall be allocated to New Service Requests in that Cycle.
Note 3: For Project Developers with System Reinforcements listed: If this project presents cost allocation to a System Reinforcement indicates $0, then please be aware that as changes to the interconnection process occur, such as other projects withdrawing, reducing in size, etc, the cost responsibilities can change and a cost allocation may be assigned to this project. In addition, although this project presents cost allocation to a System Reinforcement is presently $0, this project may need this system reinforcement completed to be deliverable to the PJM system. If this project desires to come into service prior to completion of the system reinforcement, the Project Developer will need to request PJM to perform an interim study to determine if they would be deliverable for all or a portion of their output for each delivery year until the system reinforcement is complete.
Note 4: Please see the ‘Affected Systems Studies’ section of this Phase II SIS report for details on your project’s need for an Affected Systems Study. If your project requires an Affected Systems Study, the Affected Systems impacts may not be available from the Affected System Operator at the time of the PJM Phase II SIS. Therefore, the cost in this section would not reflect any required upgrades by the Affected System until the study is completed. If your project requires an Affected Systems Study and your results are not provided for Phase II SIS, PJM anticipates providing them in the Phase III SIS per Tariff Part VII.D.312.
Readiness Deposit
Per Tariff Part VII, Subpart D, section 311 (Decision Point II) A.1.b and PJM Manual 14H, section 6.2, Readiness Deposit #3 (RD3) are funds committed by the Project Developer or Eligible Customer based upon the applicable contribution to Network Upgrades as defined below. Readiness Deposits are not used to fund studies nor to offset Security.
During Decision Point II (DP2), the Project Developer or Eligible Customer is required to submit Readiness Deposit #3, which is calculated as 20% of cost allocation for required Phase II Network Upgrades minus Readiness Deposit #1 & Readiness Deposit #2.
Note 1: “Network Upgrades” referred to in the calculation include both (i) the Physical Interconnection Network Upgrades and (ii) the System Reliability Network Upgrades as shown in the Cost Summary table.
Note 2: Readiness Deposit #1 (RD1) = ($4,000 * Project Size (MW))
Note 3: Readiness Deposit #2 (RD2) = 10% of cost allocation for required Network Upgrades minus RD1. Readiness Deposit #2 (RD2) can be zero, but may not be a negative number.
Note 4: Readiness Deposit #3 can be zero, but may not be a negative number.
Readiness Deposit #3 Due for Project AG2-329
Readiness Deposit #3 has been calculated for the project based on the Phase II System Impact Study results and is shown in the table below. This Readiness Deposit #3 must be provided at Decision Point II through either a wire transfer or letter of credit per Manual 14H, Section 6.2.
Readiness Deposit #3 Due for AG2-329
For additional detail regarding Readiness Deposit Refunds, reference PJM Manual 14H, section 6.2.1. The Readiness Deposit Letter of Credit template can be found here.
Transmission Owner Scope of Work
The total preliminary cost estimate for the Transmission Owner scope of work (including TOIF and Physical Interconnection Network Upgrades) is given in the table below. These costs do not include CIAC Tax Gross-up.
Transmission Owner Build Option
| Network Upgrades | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will review and revise (as needed) the protective relay settings at the South Berwick 345 kV Station. | $68,134 | $106,498 | $38,954 | $50,326 | $263,912 | $263,912 |
| (Pending) | Galion – South Berwick 345 kV line will be cut and looped into the new interconnection substation. | $584,791 | $56,939 | $137,513 | $16,647 | $795,890 | $795,890 |
| (Pending) | Galion Substation Protection Upgrade | $46,692 | $0 | $1,947 | $0 | $48,639 | $48,639 |
| Other | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | Installation of a standard revenue metering package, including three (3) single phase current transformers (CT), three (3) single phase coupling capacitor voltage transformers (CCVT), associated structures and foundations, one (1) ethernet switch, and one (1) DICM-installed metering panel, for the generation lead circuit at the AG2-329 New Station 345 kV Station. | $534,797 | $346,663 | $144,903 | $91,190 | $1,117,553 | $1,117,553 |
| Stand-Alone Network Upgrades | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | Installation of two (2) Carrier Protection panels at the AG2-329 New Station 345 kV Station. AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will transition existing OPGW fiber-optic shield wire from the cut-in dead ends into the AG2-329 New 345 kV Station. AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will install 1 mile of 144 count all dielectric self supporting (ADSS) fiber-optic cable. AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will install 1 mile of 144 count all dielectric loose tube (ADLT) underground fiber-optic cable. | $576,141 | $181,045 | $202,086 | $62,618 | $1,021,890 | $1,021,890 |
| (Pending) | A new breaker and a half station, to be operated as a three (3) circuit breaker ring bus, initially expandable to six (6) circuit breakers, AG2-329 New Station 345 kV, will be constructed along the Galion – South Berwick 345 kV transmission line to interconnect the project with the OHTCO transmission system. Installation of (3) 345KV RCVTs with (3) single-phase 345KV CCVT structures, foundations, and adapter steel. AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will construct a new 345 kV breaker and a half station, to be operated as a three (3) circuit breaker ring bus, initially expandable to six (6) circuit breakers. This typical arrangement is planned to be designed to accommodate 5000A of continuous current. Installation of two 2 wavetraps. four 4 single pole, single circuit, steel tangent structure. Less than 1 mile of gravel access road. Two 2 single pole, single circuit, steel running angle structure. AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will remove one 1 steel lattice structure in the Galion – South Berwick 345 kV Right of Way. | $9,781,799 | $11,040,827 | $2,431,156 | $2,747,747 | $26,001,529 | $26,001,529 |
| Transmission Owner Interconnection Facilities | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | A 345 kV dead-end structure and foundation outside the fence of the Interconnection Substation, to terminate the Project Developer’s generator lead line. Line conductor from the dead-end structure to the bus position in the switchyard of the interconnection substation. The OHTCO Interconnection Facilities will include but are not limited to the following: • Installation of one (1) new steel, 120', single circuit, single pole dead end structure on a concrete pier foundation with an anchor bolt cage and one span of double bundle ACSR 954 (Cardinal) transmission line conductor with 7#8 Alumoweld shield wire for the generation lead circuit extending from the AG2-329 New 345 kV Station. | $737,022 | $584,658 | $188,540 | $149,563 | $1,659,783 | $1,659,783 |
Developer Build Option
Project Developer has the option ("Option to Build") to assume responsibility for the design, procurement and construction of Transmission Owner Interconnection Facilities and/or Stand-Alone Network Upgrades.
If Option to Build is elected, the Project Developer must fulfill additional requirements in accordance to PJM Manual 14C, section 5.1 and PJM Manual 14H, section 8.6.2.
The cost estimates for eligible facilities and Option to Build oversight are highlighted below:
| Network Upgrades | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | AEP Ohio Transmission Company Inc. will review and revise (as needed) the protective relay settings at the South Berwick 345 kV Station. | $68,134 | $106,498 | $38,954 | $50,326 | $263,912 | $263,912 |
| (Pending) | Galion – South Berwick 345 kV line will be cut and looped into the new interconnection substation. | $584,791 | $56,939 | $137,513 | $16,647 | $795,890 | $795,890 |
| (Pending) | Galion Substation Protection Upgrade | $46,692 | $0 | $1,947 | $0 | $48,639 | $48,639 |
| Option to Build Oversight | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | Oversight of developer design and construction of new interconnection substation | $409,606 | $123,028 | $276,344 | $83,002 | $891,980 | $891,980 |
| Other | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTEP ID | Description | Direct | Indirect | Total Cost ($USD) | Allocated Cost ($USD) | ||
| Labor | Materials | Labor | Materials | ||||
| (Pending) | Installation of a standard revenue metering package, including three (3) single phase current transformers (CT), three (3) single phase coupling capacitor voltage transformers (CCVT), associated structures and foundations, one (1) ethernet switch, and one (1) DICM-installed metering panel, for the generation lead circuit at the AG2-329 New Station 345 kV Station. | $534,797 | $346,663 | $144,903 | $91,190 | $1,117,553 | $1,117,553 |
| Build Option Price Comparison | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Build Option | Total Cost | Allocated Cost | |||||
| Transmission Owner Build Option | $30,909,196 | $30,909,196 | |||||
| Developer Build Option | $3,117,974 | $3,117,974 | |||||
Based on the scope of work for the Interconnection Facilities, it is expected to take 42 month(s) after the signing of a Generator Interconnection Agreement (as this is a FERC connection) and construction kickoff call to complete the installation of the physical connection work. This assumes that there will be no environmental issues with any of the new properties associated with this project, that there will be no delays in acquiring the necessary permits for implementing the defined interconnection work, and that all system outages will be allowed when requested.
Note that the TO findings were made from a conceptual review of this project. A more detailed review of the connection facilities and their cost will be identified in a future study phase. Further note that the cost estimate data provided should be considered high level estimates since it was produced without a detailed engineering review. The Project Developer will be responsible for the actual cost of construction. TO herein reserves the right to return to any issues in this document and, upon appropriate justification, request additional monies to complete any reinforcements to the transmission systems.
Remote Terminal Work: During Phase II of the PJM interconnection process, TO’s System Protection Engineering Department will review transmission line protection as well as anti-islanding required to accommodate the new generation and interconnection substation. System Protection Engineering will determine the minimal acceptable protection requirements to reliably interconnect the proposed generating facility with the transmission system. The review is based on maintaining system reliability by reviewing TO’s protection requirements with the known transmission system configuration which includes generating facilities in the area. This review may determine that transmission line protection and communication upgrades are required at remote substations.
Remote end work required:
Please note that your project interconnects directly to an AEP facility which shares a tie line with ATSI. The Transmission Owner Scope of Work above outlines the interconnection facilities required on the AEP facilities. Your project will also require upgrades at the remote end ATSI facility. The scope, cost and schedule of work required on the ATSI facilities is provided in the PJM Phase II SIS report.
Transmission Owner Analysis
Transmission Owner Identified Network Impacts to Distribution Facilities
None
Transmission Owner Identified Network Impacts to Sub-Regional Facilities
The Transmission Owner identified network impacts to Sub-Regional facilities as follows:
| Overloaded Element | Contingency | Rating [MVA] | Final Cycle Loading % | Contribution [MW] |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 245630 05S TIFFIN 69.0 - 245713 05SENECA SS 69.0 CKT 1 | AEP_P1-2_#2748_18437_SRT-A CONTINGENCY 'AEP_P1-2_#2748_18437_SRT-A' OPEN BRANCH FROM BUS 242936 TO BUS 242942 CKT 1 / 242936 05FOSTOR 345 242942 05SBERWI 345 1 END | 86.0 | 104.55 % | 17.83 |
Transmission Owner Identified System Reinforcements on Distribution Facilities
None
Transmission Owner Identified System Reinforcements on Sub-Regional Facilities
| AG2-329 Transmission Owner Identified System Reinforcements Cost Breakdown: | TO | RTEP ID / TO ID | Title | MW Impact | Percent Allocation | Allocated Cost ($USD) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AEP | (Pending) / AEP-TC2-242 | Seneca - Tiffin: Rating Correction | 17.8 MW | 100.0% | $0 |
| Grand Total: | $0 | ||||
| System Reinforcement | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| TO | RTEP ID / TO ID | Title | Total Cost |
| AEP | (Pending) / AEP-TC2-242 | Seneca - Tiffin: Rating Correction | $0 |
Contributor
Description: Correct light load ratings are 75 MVA normal, 91 MVA emergency
| Cost Allocation | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Project | MW Impact | Percent Allocation | Allocated Cost ($USD) |
| AG2-329 | 17.8 MW | 100.0% | $0 |
Developer Requirements
The developer is responsible for all design and construction related activities on the developer’s side of the Point of Change in Ownership. AEP interconnection requirements can be found here.
To the extent that these Applicable Technical Requirements and Standards may conflict with the terms and conditions of the Tariff, the Tariff shall control.
Revenue Metering and SCADA Requirements
The developer will be required to install equipment necessary to provide Revenue Metering (KWH, KVARH) and real time data (KW, KVAR) for their generating Resource. See PJM Manual 01, PJM Manual 14D, and PJM Tariff Part IX, Subpart B, Appendix 2, section 8.Transmission Owner Requirements
The Project Developer will be required to comply with all interconnected Transmission Owner’s revenue metering requirements located at the following link: PJM - Transmission Owner Engineering & Construction Standards.
Summer Peak Analysis
The New Service Request AG2-329 was evaluated as a 200.0 MW (156.0 MW Capacity) injection in the AEP area.
AG2-329 was evaluated as part of a plant. The total Energy output of the plant was evaluated at its maximum seasonal capability of 200.0 MW (200.0 MW under study).
Note: The capacity portion of Generation Interconnection Requests are evaluated for single or N-1 contingencies. The energy portion, ramped up to a percentage of its full energy output based on season and fuel-specific ramping limits, of Generation Interconnection Requests are evaluated for multiple facility (common mode) contingencies (double circuit tower line, fault with a stuck breaker, and bus fault). For additional details regarding Generator Deliverability, reference PJM Manual 14B, Attachment C, Section C.3.
The following flowgates remain after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.
(No impacts were found for this analysis)
The following flowgates were eliminated after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.
(No flowgates were eliminated after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.)
Winter Peak Analysis
The New Service Request AG2-329 was evaluated as a 200.0 MW (156.0 MW Capacity) injection in the AEP area.
AG2-329 was evaluated as part of a plant. The total Energy output of the plant was evaluated at its maximum seasonal capability of 200.0 MW (200.0 MW under study).
Note: The energy portion, ramped up to a percentage of its full energy output based on season and fuel-specific ramping limits, of Generation Interconnection Requests are evaluated for single or N-1 contingencies and multiple facility (common mode) contingencies (double circuit tower line, fault with a stuck breaker, and bus fault). For additional details regarding Generator Deliverability, reference PJM Manual 14B, Attachment C, Section C.3.
The following flowgates remain after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.
| Study | Area | Facility Description | Contingency Name | Contingency Type | DC|AC | Final Cycle Loading | Rating (MVA) | Rating Type | MVA to Mitigate | MW Contribution | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| IPD | AEP | 05CLOVRD_RJO-05JOSHUA 765.0 kV Ckt 1 line | AP_P1-2_PE-765-242508-237805_SRT-A_SENS | Single | AC | 179.68 % | 1180.0 | B | 2120.16 | 11.95 | |
| IPD | AEP | 05CLOVRD_RJO-05JOSHUA 765.0 kV Ckt 1 line | AP_P2-3_PE-765-237805-SB4_SRT-W_SENS | Breaker | AC | 179.67 % | 1180.0 | B | 2120.16 | 11.95 | |
| IPD | AEP | 05CLOVRD_RJO-05JOSHUA 765.0 kV Ckt 1 line | AP_P2-3_PE-765-237805-SB3_SRT-W_SENS | Breaker | AC | 179.67 % | 1180.0 | B | 2120.16 | 11.95 | |
| IPD | AEP | 05CLOVRD_RJO-05JOSHUA 765.0 kV Ckt 1 line | AP_P1-2_PE-765-237805-237806_SRT-A_SENS | Single | AC | 179.67 % | 1180.0 | B | 2120.16 | 11.95 |
The following flowgates were eliminated after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.
(No flowgates were eliminated after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.)
Light Load Analysis
The New Service Request AG2-329 was evaluated as a 200.0 MW injection and 200.0 MW withdrawal in the AEP area.
AG2-329 was evaluated as part of a plant. The total Energy output of the plant was evaluated at its maximum seasonal capability of 200.0 MW (200.0 MW under study).
Note: The capacity portion of Generation Interconnection Requests are evaluated for single or N-1 contingencies. The energy portion, ramped up to a percentage of its full energy output based on season and fuel-specific ramping limits, of Generation Interconnection Requests are evaluated for multiple facility (common mode) contingencies (double circuit tower line, fault with a stuck breaker, and bus fault). For additional details regarding Generator Deliverability, reference PJM Manual 14B, Attachment C, Section C.3.
The following flowgates remain after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.
(No impacts were found for this analysis)
The following flowgates were eliminated after considering the topology reinforcements required by the cycle.
| Study | Area | Facility Description | Contingency Name | Contingency Type | DC|AC | Final Cycle Loading | Rating (MVA) | Rating Type | MVA to Mitigate | MW Contribution | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| GD2 | AEP | 05E LIMA-05SW LIM 345.0 kV Ckt 1 line | AEP_P1-2_#6497_SRT-A | Single | AC | 105.4 % | 971.0 | B | 1023.39 | 11.87 |
Short Circuit Analysis
Analysis Complete - No Issues
Based on PJM’s TC2 Phase II Short Circuit Analysis, this project did not contribute >1% fault duty to any previously identified overdutied breakers, nor did it cause any new overdutied breakers.
Please note that in TC2 Phase III, PJM will perform additional analysis including the evaluation of impacts from topology upgrades which may have potential effects on breaker duties not seen in the Phase II analysis.
Stability Analysis
Analysis Complete - No Issues
Executive Summary
New Service Requests AG2-329 and AH1-282 in PJM Transition Cycle 2, Cluster 27 are listed in Error! Reference source not found. below. This report will cover the dynamic analysis of Cluster 27 projects.
This analysis is effectively a screening study to determine whether the addition of the Cluster 27 projects will meet the dynamics requirements of the NERC, AEP and PJM reliability standards.
The load flow scenario for the analysis was based on the RTEP 2028 Summer Peak, modified to include applicable projects. Cluster 27 projects have been dispatched online at maximum power output, with 1.0 voltage at the terminal bus.
Transition Cycle 2 Cluster 27 will be tested for compliance with NERC, PJM and other applicable criteria. The contingencies will be studied with a 20 second simulation time. Contingencies to be studied include:
a) Steady-state operation (Category P0);
b) Three-phase faults with normal clearing time (and with unsuccessful high-speed reclosing) (Category P1);
c) Single-phase bus faults with normal clearing time (Category P2);
d) Single-phase faults with stuck breaker (Category P4);
e) Three-phase faults with loss of multiple-circuit tower line; (and with unsuccessful high-speed reclosing) (Category P7).
High Speed Reclosing (HSR) facilities were found in the vicinity of TC2 Cluster 27 projects.
Prior outage scenarios will not be considered for this study.
For all simulations, the queue project under study along with the rest of the PJM system were required to maintain synchronism and with all states returning to an acceptable new condition following the disturbance.
For all the fault contingencies tested on the 2028 peak load case:
a) Cluster 27 projects were able to ride through the faults (except for faults where protective action trips a generator(s)).
b) The system with Cluster 27 projects included is transiently stable and post-contingency oscillations were positively damped with a damping margin of at least 3% for interarea modes and 4% for local modes.
c) Following fault clearing, all bus voltages recovered to a minimum of 0.7 per unit after 2.5 seconds (except where protective action isolates that bus).
d) No transmission element tripped, other than those either directly connected or designed to trip because of that fault.
No mitigations were found to be required.
Table 1: Transition Cycle 2 Cluster 27 Projects |
|
|
|
|
Project | Fuel Type | Transmission Owner | MFO (MW) | Point of Interconnection |
AG2-329 | Battery | AEP | 200 | South Berwick - Galion 345 kV |
AH1-282 | Solar | AEP | 49.9 | Galion - Ohio Central 345 kV |
Reactive Power Analysis
Analysis Complete - No Issues
The reactive power capability of AG2-329 meets the 0.95 leading and lagging PF requirement at the high side of the main transformer.
Steady-State Voltage Analysis
Analysis Complete - No Issues
Steady State Voltage Analysis complete, no voltage issues identified.
New Service Request Dependencies
The New Service Requests below are listed in one or more dispatch for the overloads identified in this report. These projects contribute to the loading of the overloaded facilities identified in this report. The percent overload of a facility and cost allocation you may have towards a particular reinforcement could vary depending on the action of other projects. The status of each project at the time of the analysis is presented in the table. This list may change as other projects withdraw or modify their requests. This table is valid for load flow analyses only.
(No dependencies were identified)
Affected System - PJM Identified Violations
As part of PJM's analysis, per Tariff Part VII.G.336 & Manual 14H, Section 13, PJM evaluated the potential impacts on tie line facilities between PJM and an affected system entity, which were identified per PJM planning analysis criteria. This upgrade may be required on the affected system portion of the tie line along with cost allocation of such upgrade if applicable, in coordination with the affected system. Depending on the affected system, this project may not be contingent on upgrade based on PJM planning analysis criteria, but may be contingent on this upgrade based on the Affected System Operator's planning criteria, provided in the Affected Systems Study Section, herein.
Affected System - Non-PJM Identified Violations
In accordance with PJM Tariff Part VII, Subpart D, section 310.A and as outlined in PJM Manual 14H, Sections 4.5 and 13, in Phase II of the Cycle, PJM provides the Affected System Operator any updates on the PJM projects that require an Affected Systems Study based on their response at DP1. New Service Requests that require an Affected Systems Study are required to enter into an Affected Systems Study Agreement with the Affected System Operator, as applicable, prior to the close of DP2 or they will be withdrawn from the Cycle.
If the Project Developer already entered into the necessary agreement and the results are available, PJM will supply them in the Phase II SIS report. See below for the status of any required Affected Systems Study. A status of “Pending” means that the study is not yet completed by the Affected System Operator. If your project requires an Affected Systems Study and your results are not provided for Phase II SIS, PJM anticipates providing them in the Phase III SIS per Tariff Part VII.D.312.
System Reinforcements
Based on the Phase II System Impact Study analysis results, this project is contingent on and may have cost responsibility for the following System Reinforcements:
| TO | RTEP ID | Title | Category | Allocated Cost ($USD) | Facilities Study |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AEP | b4068.1 | b4068: Greentown 765 kV - Teddy 765kV - Marysville 765 kV - Greenfield Line - AEP Proposal 570 | Contingent | $0 | N/A |
| AEP | b3919.1 | Reconfigure Maliszewski 765 kV station and establish 345 kV breaker yard | Contingent | $0 | N/A |
| AEP | b4000.251 | Replace the wave trap and upgrade the relay at Cloverdale 765kV substation | Contingent | $0 | N/A |
| AEP | b4000.252 | Replace the wave trap and upgrade the relay at Joshua Falls 765kV substation | Contingent | $0 | N/A |
| Grand Total: | $0 | ||||
Shown below are the details of the cost allocated, contingent, eliminated, topology and potential aggregate contributor reinforcements for this project. Please refer to the System Reinforcement table above and the information below for more detail.
System Reinforcement: b4068.1
- Type
- Load Flow
- TO
- AEP
- RTEP ID / TO ID
- b4068.1 / AEP-TC2-18693
- Title
- b4068: Greentown 765 kV - Teddy 765kV - Marysville 765 kV - Greenfield Line - AEP Proposal 570
- Description
- b4068.1 through b4068.49: Affected Transmission Owners: AEP / Dayton / ATSI The objective of this project is to construct multiple transmission lines to address Ohio area violations. The total distance covered by the lines is approximately 359.54 miles. The first transmission line ranges from the existing Greentown Substation in Howard County, Indiana to the new Teddy Substation in Clark County, Ohio, the line then branches north towards the existing Marysville Substation in Union County, Ohio, and east to the existing Beatty Substation in Franklin County, Ohio, and then extends to the existing Cole Substation in Franklin County, Ohio. The second transmission line extends from the existing Adkins Substation in Pickaway County, Ohio, to the new West Millersport Substation in Fairfield County, Ohio, then continues to the existing Conesville Substation in Coshocton County, Ohio before finally extending to the existing Guernsey Substation in Guernsey County, Ohio. There is a total of five transmission lines that extend between unnamed substations (Hayden - Cole 345 kV, Hyatt - Maliszewski 345 kV [double circuit], Roberts - Kenny 138 kV, Wilson - 5th Avenue 138 kV, West Millersport-Kirk 345 kV). This project will traverse 4 counties (Howard, Grant, Blackford, Jay) in Indiana, and 13 counties (Darke, Shelby, Champaign, Clark, Madison, Franklin, Delaware, Pickaway, Fairfield, Licking, Muskingum, Coshocton, Guernsey) in Ohio. This proposal has a total of 38 components, including 16 substation upgrade components, two greenfield substation components, eight greenfield transmission line components covering approximately 336.2 miles, and 12 transmission line upgrade components covering approximately 23.34 miles. b4068.28/b4068.49 is dependent on b3919.1 Baseline completion.
- Cost Information
- Time Estimate
- Jun 01 2030
ContingentTopology Changing Note 1: Although AG2-329 may not presently have cost responsibility for this upgrade, AG2-329 may need this upgrade in-service to be deliverable to the PJM system. If AG2-329 desires to come into service prior to completion of the upgrade, the Project Developer will need to request PJM to perform an interim study to determine if they would be deliverable for all or a portion of their output for each delivery year until the upgrade is complete. Note 2: This topology changing reinforcement was developed by the transmission owner and modeled in PJM analysis to address cycle overload(s). A flowgate that this project contributed to was identified as requiring this topology reinforcement.
| Facility | Contingency | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 05E LIMA-05SW LIM 345.0 kV Ckt 1 line | (Any) | No new ratings for this Flowgate. |
System Reinforcement: b3919.1
- Type
- Load Flow
- TO
- AEP
- RTEP ID / TO ID
- b3919.1
- Title
- Reconfigure Maliszewski 765 kV station and establish 345 kV breaker yard
- Description
- Reconfigure Maliszewski 765 kV station from 2 breakers to a 6 breaker ring bus. Install a new 765/345 kV transformer. Establish new 345 kV breaker yard with 3 string breaker and a half to include a line exit to Hyatt and a line exit to Corridor. Loop the existing Hyatt - West Millersport 345 kV line into the new established 345 kV yard at the Maliszewski station.
- Cost Information
- Time Estimate
- Jun 01 2029
ContingentTopology Changing Note 1: Although AG2-329 may not presently have cost responsibility for this upgrade, AG2-329 may need this upgrade in-service to be deliverable to the PJM system. If AG2-329 desires to come into service prior to completion of the upgrade, the Project Developer will need to request PJM to perform an interim study to determine if they would be deliverable for all or a portion of their output for each delivery year until the upgrade is complete. Note 2: This topology changing reinforcement was developed by the transmission owner and modeled in PJM analysis to address cycle overload(s). A flowgate that this project contributed to was identified as requiring this topology reinforcement.
| Facility | Contingency | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| 05E LIMA-05SW LIM 345.0 kV Ckt 1 line | (Any) | No new ratings for this Flowgate. |
System Reinforcement: b4000.251
- Type
- Load Flow
- TO
- AEP
- RTEP ID / TO ID
- b4000.251
- Title
- Replace the wave trap and upgrade the relay at Cloverdale 765kV substation
- Description
- Replace the wave trap and upgrade the relay at Cloverdale 765kV substation
- Cost Information
- Time Estimate
- Jun 01 2029
Contingent Note: Although AG2-329 may not presently have cost responsibility for this upgrade, AG2-329 may need this upgrade in-service to be deliverable to the PJM system. If AG2-329 desires to come into service prior to completion of the upgrade, the Project Developer will need to request PJM to perform an interim study to determine if they would be deliverable for all or a portion of their output for each delivery year until the upgrade is complete.
| Facility | Contingency | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 05JOSHUA-05CLOVRD_RJO 765.0 kV Ckt 1 line | (Any) |
|
System Reinforcement: b4000.252
- Type
- Load Flow
- TO
- AEP
- RTEP ID / TO ID
- b4000.252
- Title
- Replace the wave trap and upgrade the relay at Joshua Falls 765kV substation
- Description
- Replace the wave trap and upgrade the relay at Joshua Falls 765kV substation
- Cost Information
- Time Estimate
- Jun 01 2029
Contingent Note: Although AG2-329 may not presently have cost responsibility for this upgrade, AG2-329 may need this upgrade in-service to be deliverable to the PJM system. If AG2-329 desires to come into service prior to completion of the upgrade, the Project Developer will need to request PJM to perform an interim study to determine if they would be deliverable for all or a portion of their output for each delivery year until the upgrade is complete.
| Facility | Contingency | |||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 05JOSHUA-05CLOVRD_RJO 765.0 kV Ckt 1 line | (Any) |
|