Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee (RAAS) reviews the modeling and analysis techniques used in the annual Reserve Requirement Study (RRS) and Capacity Emergency Transfer Objective (CETO) studies. The RAAS reports to the Planning Committee (PC).

Chair: Tom Falin
Secretary: Jason Quevada

Meeting Dates

04.05.2012 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting(Canceled)  Posted Materials There are no materials associated for this meeting. select all    clear all

03.02.2012 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 2.28.2012 Agenda pdfPDF 2.28.2012 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.1.2012 Ambient Deratings pdfPDF 2.28.2012 Draft Minutes - RAAS - 10.28.2011 pdfPDF 2.29.2012 Load Curves for PRISM pdfPDF 2.28.2012 2012 RRS Assumptions Letter pdfPDF 2.28.2012 2012 RRS Assumptions Appendix A pdfPDF select all    clear all

02.10.2012 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting(Canceled)  Posted Materials There are no materials associated for this meeting. select all    clear all

12.08.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting(Canceled)  Posted Materials There are no materials associated for this meeting. select all    clear all

10.28.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 10.25.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 10.25.2011 Agenda docDOC 3.26.2012 Minutes pdfPDF 10.27.2011 NERC Probabilistic Assessment Pilot Study – Initial Draft pdfPDF 10.25.2011 NERC Probabilistic Assessment Pilot Study – Summary pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.29.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 9.26.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 9.26.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 11.10.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 9.26.2011 2011 PJM Reserve Requirement Study pdfPDF 9.26.2011 Item 03 - Preliminary 2011 RRS Summary pdfPDF select all    clear all

08.31.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 8.30.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 8.30.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 8.30.2011 Item 03 - 2011 RRS Preliminary Results  pdfPDF 9.30.2011 Minutes pdfPDF select all    clear all

07.29.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 7.27.2011 Agenda  pdfPDF 7.27.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 9.6.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 7.27.2011 Item 04A - 2011 RRS World Diversity pdfPDF 7.27.2011 Item 04B - 2011 RRS World Reserve Level Valid Range pdfPDF 7.29.2011 Item 04C - 2011 RRS Load Model Time Period Selection  pdfPDF select all    clear all

07.14.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 7.13.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 7.13.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 8.26.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 7.13.2011 Item 04 - Seasonal EFORd RASS pdfPDF 7.13.2011 Item 04 - Status of Incorporating PJM Load Forecast into the PRISM Model pdfPDF select all    clear all

07.13.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee R-Study Meeting  Posted Materials There are no materials associated for this meeting. select all    clear all

06.01.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 5.26.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 5.26.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 7.20.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 5.31.2011 Item 04 - EUE and LOLH NERC Reporting Trial  pdfPDF 6.1.2011 Item 05 - CETO Loads Models pdfPDF select all    clear all

05.04.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 4.29.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 4.29.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 6.6.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 5.3.2011 Item 04 – CETO Review Action Plan xlsXLS 5.3.2011 Item 05 – Generator Peak Period Performance Analysis pdfPDF select all    clear all

04.07.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 4.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 4.4.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 5.27.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 4.5.2011 Item 03A - 2011 RRS Assumptions Letter pdfPDF 4.5.2011 Item 03B - 2011 RRS Assumptions Appendix A pdfPDF 4.5.2011 Item 04 - Manual 20 - Draft pdfPDF 4.5.2011 Item 05 - Mr. Wilson's Presentation on 1-Day-in-25 CETO Criterion  pdfPDF 4.5.2011 Item 06 - RAAS Action Plan for 2011 xlsXLS 4.5.2011 Item 07 - GE-MARS Base Case Investigations pdfPDF select all    clear all

03.24.2011 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.21.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.21.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 4.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.22.2011 Item 03 – CETO Tutorial RAAS pdfPDF 3.21.2011 Item 04 - Manual 20 Draft Changes pdfPDF 3.22.2011 Item 05 – RAAS Action Plan for 2011 xlsXLS 3.22.2011 Item 06 – 2011 RRS Assumptions Letter pdfPDF 3.22.2011 Item 06 – 2011 RRS Assumptions Appendix A pdfPDF select all    clear all

02.17.2011 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 2.10.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 2.10.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 4.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 2.10.2011 Item 03 - GAST Phase IIA - Roll-Out Presentation pdfPDF 2.10.2011 Item 04 - Resource Adequacy Analysis Subcommittee Charter pdfPDF 2.10.2011 Item 05A - PRISM - MARS Report Status pdfPDF 2.10.2011 Item 05B - Comment Tracking and Resolution pdfPDF 2.16.2011 Item 05C - PRISM - MARS Final Draft Report pdfPDF 2.10.2011 Item 06A - CETO Modeling Assumptions pdfPDF select all    clear all

12.03.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.8.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04 - PRISM MARS Report Status pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04A - Comment Tracking and Resolutions pdfPDF select all    clear all

10.25.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.8.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04A - Comparison of PRISM and MARS pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04B - Comment Tracking and Resolution pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04C - PRISM and MARS Comparison Report pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.29.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcomittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.8.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.8.2011 Item 03 - 2010 RRS Final Draft and Recommendations pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04 - Winter Weekly Reserve for 2010 pdfPDF 3.8.2011 2010 PJM Reserve Requirement Study pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.21.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.8.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.8.2011 2010 PJM Reserve Requirement Study - Draft pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.07.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.8.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 03A - 2010 RRS Preliminary Results  pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 03B - Executive Summary pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 03C - Appendix A pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 03D - Appendix B pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04 - Generator Peak Period Performance Analysis pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 06A - NERC LOLE WG status update to the NERC PC pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 06B - GTRPMTF Final Report pdfPDF select all    clear all

08.06.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.8.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.8.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.8.2011 Item 04 - PRISM and MARS Comparison - Status Update pdfPDF select all    clear all

07.07.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.7.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.7.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04A - Intra World Diversity pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04B - 2010 RRS Load Model Selection pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 05 - PRISM and MARS Comparison White Paper Update pdfPDF select all    clear all

06.01.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.7.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.7.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04 - PRISM and MARS Comparison White Paper Update pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 06 - GTRMPTF Status Update pdfPDF select all    clear all

05.07.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.7.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.7.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 03 - R Study Assumptions pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04 - Comparison of PRISM and MARS Status Update pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 05 - NERC LOLEWG Update pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 06 - Generator Peak Period Performance pdfPDF select all    clear all

04.09.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.7.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.7.2011 Item 03 – 2010 R Study Assumptions Draft pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 03 – PJM Reserve Requirement Study Draft Assumptions pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04A - PRISM - MARS Comparison pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04B - Comparison of PRISM and MARS Preliminary Draft pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 05A - DR Saturation Analysis pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 05B - DR Saturation Six Hours pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 07 - Updated Parking Lot Item List xlsXLS 3.7.2011 Minutes pdfPDF select all    clear all

03.12.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.7.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Agenda (DOC) docDOC 3.7.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 03 - PJM Reserve Rwquirement Study Draft Assumptions pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04A - BAL-052-RFC-02 pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 04B - Summary Document BAL-052-RFC-02 Requirements pdfPDF select all    clear all

02.05.2010 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.7.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 03 - ICAP UCAP Translations 2006-2010 xlsXLS 3.7.2011 Item 03A - ICAP UCAP Whitepaper pdfPDF 3.7.2011 Item 03 - Parking Lot Item Priority List xlsXLS select all    clear all

12.14.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF select all    clear all

10.12.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A – Discussion of Final Draft of the 2009 RRS Report pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - 2009 PJM Reserve Requirement Study - Final Draft pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.25.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - Consistence Between Load Forecast & RRS Peak Load pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - PRISM Solved Load pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A – 50/50 Peak Load Value for IRM Calculation pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04A - 2009 PJM Reserve Requirement Study Draft Report pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.10.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03 - Peak Load Value for IRM pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A – 50/50 Peak Load Value for IRM Calculation pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - Reporting on 50/50 Solution Loads pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - IRM Reporting Load xlsXLS 3.4.2011 Item 03B – Truncated Normal Distribution pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04A - Base Case Results pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04B - 2009 PJM Reserve Requirement Study Initial Draft pdfPDF select all    clear all

09.02.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - Summer Seasonal ReNormalized vs. Forecast xlsXLS 3.4.2011 Item 03A - Truncated Normal Distribution at 2.5 Sigma pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03B - World Subzones Data for Composite IRM Determination xlsXLS 3.4.2011 Item 04A – 2009 RRS Base Case Results pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04B - Syspar for Base Case pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04D - Appendix B - Sensitivities pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04E - Figure II - 7 Relation Between IRM and CBM pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 04F - Table II - 5 - Comparaison of Class Avg. Values 2008/2009 xlsXLS select all    clear all

08.19.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.4.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03A - 2009 RRS - Investigation of Possible Changes to 21-point Normal Distribution pdfPDF 3.4.2011 Item 03B - 2013 Summer Forecast Distribution xlsXLS 3.4.2011 Item 03B – Modeling of World Area xlsXLS select all    clear all

07.31.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.2.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 03A - Truncating Normal Distribution pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 03A - Truncating Normal Distribution - Further Analysis & Revised Proposal pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 03B – Modeling Of World Area pdfPDF select all    clear all

07.01.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.2.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 03A and 03B - Load Model Selection pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 04B - Truncated Normal Distribution - Updated pdfPDF select all    clear all

06.03.2009 - Reserve Requirement Assumptions Subcommittee Meeting  Posted Materials 3.2.2011 Agenda pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Minutes pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 04A – Outline of Method to Choose Time Period for Hourly Loads Used in Load Model pdfPDF 3.2.2011 Item 04E - Timeline for New RRAWG Tasks pdfPDF select all    clear all