Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
The procurement of clean resource attributes was discussed in the Resource Adequacy Senior Task Force (RASTF) as part of the RASTF charter. As a result, a separate issue charge was approved by the Markets and Reliability Committee on April 27, 2022, establishing the Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force (CAPSTF). Separately, the Organization of PJM States, Inc. (OPSI) has established the OPSI Competitive Policy Achievement Staff Working Group (CPAWG) to develop and advance reform proposals that enable the procurement of resources in line with states’ policy goals. The CAPSTF will coordinate a comprehensive discussion between the OPSI CPAWG, PJM stakeholders and PJM staff around enhancements to enable states and other willing buyers to procure clean resource attributes, on a voluntary basis, through a regional and centralized procurement or market. The CAPSTF will report to the Markets and Reliability Committee.
Facilitator: Scott Baker
Secretary: Chris Callaghan
During the meeting, if you are experiencing issues with connectivity or teleconference, please contact Meeting Support. For registration issues, contact PJM.
|
Date
|
|
|---|---|
| Issue Charge PDF | 4.18.2023 |
| OPSI - CPAWG Guidance & Request for Input PDF | 6.1.2022 |
| CPAWG Analysis Request for CAPSTF PDF | 9.19.2022 |
Modeling Results
|
Date
|
||
|---|---|---|
| Preliminary Results |
|
|
| Analysis 1 - Inputs & Annual Outputs ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 2 - Hourly Storage ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 3 - Hourly Generation 1-2C ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 4 - Hourly Generation 2D-2E ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 5 - Hourly Generation 3-4 ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 6 - Hourly Zonal 1-2E ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 7 - Hourly Zonal 3-4 ZIP |
2.24.2023
|
|
|
|
||
| Final Results |
|
|
| Analysis 1 - Inputs & Annual Outputs ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 2 - Hourly Storage ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 3 - Hourly Generation 1-2C ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 4 - Hourly Generation 2D-2E ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 5 - Hourly Generation 3-4 ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 6 - Hourly Generation IMM & Other ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 7 - Hourly Zonal 1-2E ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| Analysis 8 - Hourly Zonal 3-4 IMM & Other ZIP |
3.24.2023
|
|
| |
|
|
| Final Results of Clean Attribute Market Design Scenarios PDF |
4.18.2023
|
References
|
Date
|
||
|---|---|---|
| NJ BPU Alternative Resource Adequacy Structures PDF |
9.19.2022
|
|
| DC DOEE Toward 100 Carbon Free Electricity PDF |
9.19.2022
|
|
| New England Pathways to a Future Grid Analysis PDF |
9.19.2022
|
|
| RMI Scaling Clean PDF |
9.19.2022
|
Upcoming Meetings
|
Meeting
|
Date
|
Time
|
Attendance
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| No records found | ||||
Upcoming Meetings
| No records found |
Meeting Materials
9.22.2023 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 9.19.2023 | Agenda PDF | |
| 9.19.2023 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 9.19.2023 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 5.23.2023 PDF | |
| 9.21.2023 | Item 02a - OPSI letter re Forward Energy Attribute Market PDF | |
| 9.21.2023 | Item 02b - PJM Board reply letter re FEAM PDF | |
| 9.22.2023 | Item 03a - FEAMWG Presentation to CAPSTF PDF | |
| 9.22.2023 | Item 03b - FEAM Working Group Draft Charter PDF |
5.23.2023 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 5.18.2023 | Agenda PDF | |
| 5.18.2023 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 6.13.2023 | CAPSTF Poll & Voting Results PDF | |
| 5.18.2023 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 4.25.2023 PDF | |
| 5.18.2023 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 5.18.2023 | Item 04 - Constellation Hourly Attribute Considerations PDF | |
| 5.18.2023 | Item 05 - Vistra CAPSTF Solution Proposal PDF | |
| 5.26.2023 | Item 06 - Solutions Matrix - CAPSTF XLS |
4.25.2023 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 4.24.2023 | Agenda PDF | |
| 4.24.2023 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 4.20.2023 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 3.28.2023 PDF | |
| 4.20.2023 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 4.21.2023 | Item 04 - NJBPU Resource Adequacy Investigation PDF | |
| 4.21.2023 | Item 04 - NJBPU Staff 2022 Resource Adequacy Investigation Report PDF | |
| 4.24.2023 | Item 05 - Constellation PJM CAPSTF Modeling Discussion PDF | |
| 4.20.2023 | Item 06 - Solutions Matrix - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 4.24.2023 | Item 07 - Vistra CAPSTF Solution Proposal PDF | |
| 4.24.2023 | Item 08 - CAPSTF Voting Process PDF |
3.28.2023 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 3.23.2023 | Agenda PDF | |
| 3.23.2023 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 3.23.2023 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 2.28.2023 PDF | |
| 3.23.2023 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 3.24.2023 | Item 03 - OPSI Board Letter - CAPSTF Solution Packages PDF | |
| 3.24.2023 | Item 04 - Final Results of Clean Attribute Market Design Scenarios PDF | |
| 3.23.2023 | Item 05 - Solutions Matrix - CAPSTF XLS |
2.28.2023 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 2.27.2023 | Agenda PDF | |
| 2.27.2023 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 2.23.2023 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 1.31.2023 PDF | |
| 2.23.2023 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 2.24.2023 | Item 04 - CAPSTF Analysis Update PDF | |
| 2.23.2023 | Item 05 - Solutions Matrix - CAPSTF XLS |
1.31.2023 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 2.28.2023 | Minutes PDF | |
| 1.26.2023 | Agenda PDF | |
| 1.26.2023 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 1.26.2023 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 12.16.2022 PDF | |
| 1.26.2023 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 1.30.2023 | Item 04 - MA DOER CAPSTF Presentation PDF | |
| 1.26.2023 | Item 04 - MA DOER FCEM Design Proposal PDF | |
| 1.27.2023 | Item 05 - CAPSTF Analysis Update PDF | |
| 1.26.2023 | Item 06 - Solutions Matrix - CAPSTF XLS |
12.16.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 2.28.2023 | Minutes PDF | |
| 12.13.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 12.13.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 12.13.2022 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 11.04.2022 PDF | |
| 12.13.2022 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 12.15.2022 | Item 04 - CAPSTF Analysis Initial Results PDF | |
| 1.9.2023 | Item 04 - CAPSTF Analysis Initial Results-Post Meeting Version PDF |
11.4.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 11.1.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 11.1.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 11.4.2022 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 10.12.2022 PDF | |
| 11.2.2022 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 11.2.2022 | Item 04 - ICC Analysis Request PDF | |
| 11.2.2022 | Item 06A - CAPSTF - Model Assumptions Inputs XLS | |
| 11.2.2022 | Item 06B - CAPSTF - Generation and Batteries Inputs XLS | |
| 11.2.2022 | Item 07 - CAPSTF - Analysis Scope to-date PDF | |
| 11.2.2022 | Item 08 - Solutions Matrix - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 12.16.2022 | Minutes PDF |
10.12.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 10.7.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 10.7.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 9.21.2022 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 9.13.2022 PDF | |
| 10.7.2022 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 10.11.2022 | Item 04 - BPU Report on Resource Adequacy PDF | |
| 10.7.2022 | Item 04 - BPU Staffs 2022 Resource Adequacy Investigation Report PDF | |
| 10.11.2022 | Item 05 - REsurety Greenhouse Gas Abatement PDF | |
| 10.12.2022 | Item 06-07 - CAPSTF - Solutions Matrix XLS | |
| 10.12.2022 | Item 08 - CAPSTF - Analysis Scope To-Date PDF | |
| 10.7.2022 | Item 09 - Constellation CAPSTF Data Request PDF | |
| 10.10.2022 | Item 10 - IMM CAPSTF Modeling Request PDF | |
| 10.10.2022 | Item 11- Wilson EC CAPSTF Modeling Request PDF | |
| 12.16.2022 | Minutes PDF |
9.13.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 9.9.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 9.9.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 9.8.2022 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 8.17.2022 PDF | |
| 9.8.2022 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 9.12.2022 | Item 04 - Clean Energy Market Concept - IMM PDF | |
| 9.9.2022 | Item 05 - Perspectives on Clean Energy Procurement - Constellation PDF | |
| 9.9.2022 | Item 06A - Solutions Matrix Options - OPSI CPAWG XLS | |
| 9.7.2022 | Item 06 - Solutions Matrix XLS | |
| 9.13.2022 | Item 07 - CAPSTF Analysis Update PDF | |
| 12.16.2022 | Minutes PDF |
8.17.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 8.12.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 8.12.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 8.12.2022 | Item 01 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 7.28.2022 PDF | |
| 8.12.2022 | Item 02 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 8.12.2022 | Item 03 - ISO-NE Pathways Study PDF | |
| 8.12.2022 | Item 03 - ISO-NE Pathways Study Report PDF | |
| 8.12.2022 | Item 04 - Solutions Matrix XLS | |
| 8.12.2022 | Item 05 - Analysis Preliminary Discussion PDF | |
| 9.21.2022 | Minutes PDF |
7.28.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 7.25.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 02 - Draft Minutes - CAPSTF - 6.28.2022 PDF | |
| 7.29.2022 | Item 03 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 05 - Brattle Market Mechanics and Options PDF | |
| 7.27.2022 | Item 06 - RMI Presentation PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 06 - RMI Scaling Clean Report PDF | |
| 7.28.2022 | Item 07 - NJ BPU Presentation PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 07 - NJ BPU RA Investigation PDF | |
| 7.27.2022 | Item 08 – DC DOEE presentation PDF | |
| 7.28.2022 | Item 08 - DC DOEE Presentation PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 08 - DOEE PJM Market Study PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 09 - ISO-NE Pathways Study PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 09 - ISO-NE Pathways Study Report PDF | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 10 - CAPSTF - Solutions Matrix XLS | |
| 7.25.2022 | Item 11 - CPAWG Analysis Request for CAPSTF PDF | |
| 8.18.2022 | Minutes PDF |
6.28.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 7.1.2022 | Item 03 - Work Plan - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 7.1.2022 | Item 07 - Solutions Matrix - Post Meeting - CAPSTF XLS | |
| 7.29.2022 | Minutes PDF | |
| 6.23.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 6.23.2022 | Agenda-doc DOC | |
| 6.23.2022 | Item 04 - CPAWG Analysis Request for CAPSTF PDF | |
| 6.24.2022 | Item 05 - Local Government Presentation to PJM CAPSTF PDF | |
| 6.24.2022 | Item 06 - CEBI NextGen Initiative PDF |
6.3.2022 - Clean Attribute Procurement Senior Task Force
| 5.31.2022 | Agenda PDF | |
| 5.31.2022 | Agenda DOC | |
| 6.28.2022 | Minutes PDF | |
| 5.31.2022 | Item 02 - Work Plan XLS | |
| 5.31.2022 | Item 03 - OPSI Education & Perspectives PDF | |
| 5.31.2022 | Item 04 - PJM EIS GATS Education PDF | |
| 5.31.2022 | Item 05 - What is a Clean Attribute? PDF | |
| 5.31.2022 | Item 06 - Consensus Based Issue Resolution Process PDF |
Materials submitted to PJM by PJM Members or any other stakeholder for posting on PJM.com shall not imply support or endorsement by PJM Interconnection.